The 6 Best Key Lime Pies in Key West Florida

The 6 Best Key Lime Pies in Key West, Florida: A Tasting Guide

Key West is famous for its Key Lime pie, a tart and sweet dessert that perfectly captures the spirit of this sunny island. Here’s a look at six spots that serve up some of the best Key Lime pies in Key West, Florida. Each has its unique flavor and texture that makes it stand out.

Best Key Lime Pies

Blue Heaven

Blue Heaven’s Key Lime pie is famous for its tall meringue topping. The pie has a perfect balance of sweetness and tartness. The meringue is light and fluffy, while the filling is rich and smooth. The crust is crumbly and slightly sweet, adding to the overall experience.

What Stands Out: The towering meringue gives it a unique look and adds an airy texture.

Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shoppe

Kermit’s is a must-visit for Key Lime pie lovers. Their pie is known for its refreshing, citrusy flavor and smooth, velvety texture. The crust is light and flaky, perfectly complementing the tart filling. Kermit’s pie is also available dipped in chocolate for a sweet and tangy combination.

What Stands Out: The refreshing lime taste and the option for a chocolate-covered version.

Best Key Lime Pies at Publix

Publix, a popular grocery store, offers a surprisingly good Key Lime pie. It’s not as fancy as some of the others, but it delivers a satisfying lime flavor with a creamy consistency. The crust is thick and has a nice crunch, and the pie is consistently good. It’s the perfect mix of not too sweet and not too tart. Locals suggest that several long-time residents of Key West are the reason Publix pies are so good.

What Stands Out is the reliable flavor and texture, the convenience of picking it up from a grocery store, and the price. A whole pie at Publix costs what one slice does at the other places.

Original Key Lime Pie Bakery

The Original Key Lime Pie Bakery keeps it simple and classic making it one of the best key lime pies. Their pie has a strong lime flavor with a creamy texture. The crust is crunchy and buttery, providing a great contrast to the smooth filling. If you love a pie that stays true to tradition, this is the place to go.

What Stands Out: The bold, zesty lime flavor and the authentic, no-frills approach.

Kaya Island Eats

Kaya’s has a fun and happy atmosphere, and one of the best key lime pies. Their pie is a bit more tangy, with a buttery thin graham cracker crust that nicely accompanies the pie filling. The pie has a firm filling that holds together well. A dense, chewy meringue on top enhanced it overall.

What Stands Out: The saltier crust and the extra tangy filling that give it a distinct taste.

Two Friends Patio Restaurant

Two Friends Patio Restaurant serves a rich and smooth key lime pie. The filling is creamy and has a well-balanced lime flavor, neither too sweet nor too tart. The buttery crust adds a nice contrast to the filling. It’s a solid choice for anyone looking to enjoy this classic dessert.

Two Friends has great food overall, with large portions that aren’t overpriced. The key lime pie is superb, especially the pie crust. It’s one of the best in Key West.

What Stands Out: The rich, creamy texture and the balanced lime flavor.

I have a few key lime-inspired recipes that have become reader favorites.

• Key Lime Cake with Key Lime Cream Cheese Frosting
• Scratch Made Key Lime Pound Cake Recipe with Key Lime Glaze
• KEY LIME COCONUT MARBLED POUND CAKE
• Three Ingredient Fresh Peach Hand Pies
• BIG BEAUTIFUL CAKES

Best Key Lime Pies Conclusion

Each of these places in Key West offers a Key Lime pie with its unique twist. Whether you prefer a pie with a traditional taste, a towering meringue, or a chocolate-dipped version, Key West has something for every Key Lime pie lover. If you’re in town, make sure to try a slice from each spot and decide for yourself which one is the best.